Doing Messianic Jewish Halacha
The word “Halacha” comes from the Hebrew word, ללכת – “to walk.” It is a technical term used for the rules that govern Jewish religious life. The term “Halacha” is an ancient term that is already reflected in the New Testament especially in Paul’s letters. Paul uses the word, “walk” in some form in almost in every one of his letters. The word “walk” introduces practical instructions as to the way that the “Christian” should walk and conduct his life. Following will be a few examples of this point:
“And they were both righteous before God, walking in all the commandments and ordinances of the Lord blameless.”
“And they are informed of thee, that thou teachest all the Jews that are among the Gentiles to forsake Moses, saying that they ought not to circumcise their children, neither to walk after the customs.”
“Let us walk honestly, as in the day; not in rioting and drunkenness, not in chambering and wantonness, not in strife and envying.”
I Corinthians 7:17
“But as God hath distributed to every man, as the Lord hath called every one, so let him walk. And so ordain I in all churches.”
There are many more examples of the use of this term “walk” in the context of Halacha, but I will satisfy myself with those listed above. For the more diligent they can check their concordance or look up the list of passages listed in the footnote.
From these passages there seems to be a clear indication that in the First Century Church there was a Messianic Halacha being made, and that it was even to some degree even referred to as a “walk.” We find ruling made by Apostles that are not identified as “walking.” Even in these it is clear that a “rule” or an “ordinance” is being legislated for the churches to observe. The Apostles understood from the words of Yeshua in Matthew 16:19, that they have the right to “bind” and “loose” on Earth. The words of Yeshua are clearonlyinthecontextofJewish“makingofHalacha.”TheauthorityisgivenherebyYeshuatotheApostles that whatever decisions they will make on Earth will be acceptable and would become “bound” in Heaven. This is the exact same authority that the Rabbis took upon themselves. There is a famous statement in the Talmud that, “Whatever the Rabbis bind will be bound in Heaven, and Whatever the Blessed be His name￼binds on they Rabbis they have the authority to loose.” Although in this case the Rabbis seem to have taken their authority a little too far, the principle is the same. Yeshua seems to give the Apostles the right to make “Halacha” by His authority.
This principle was the guiding principle that led to the establishment of “Canon Law” which is just another name for “Halacha.” And, of course, this is what led to the establishment of the Holy Catholic Church in Rome.
One of the major principles of making Halacha in Judaism was lacking seriously when Christians made “Halacha,” and that is the strict adherence to the text of the Torah according to the exegetical rules for interpretation. The battles between the Rabbis on every point and, in fact, on every letter, kept the making of Halacha a very serious and laborious task and away from a dictatorial “ex-cathedra” attitude that prevailed in the church.
This brings me to the discussion of the Messianic Jewish movement today and the need for Messianic Jewish Halacha.
- At this time in our history as a Movement we do not have either the heritage nor the equipment to do Halacha. Doing Halacha is something that we will have to develop with a lot of care.
- We are still divided according to the traditional Christian denominational lines. Doing Halacha might serve to divide us even more if we it is done to fast.
- We have very little integrity in both the eyes of the Jewish community and in the eyes of our Christian brothers.
- We do not have men who have a wide respect in both the Messianic and the Christian communities that could pull behind them a wide acceptance of Halachic decision that might be made. We do have man who think that they are qualified, but that is not enough.
- We have very little knowledge of the Torah and Judaism, and our integrity as a Jewish movement is in question by both Jews and Christians. Taking upon ourselves such a task as doing Halacha would be seen by many as one more blow to our integrity and theology.
- We still receive money from the Gentile Churches and that makes us suspect of being “un-objective” and “bribed” in our opinions.
- We have needs that are too hot, and the situation is an infected tooth. One does not make Halacha in the heat of an infection. We have to make Halacha when we are as detached from internal politics and power plays as possible.
- We do not want to be more divisive by making “rules of conduct” that only a very small minority will observe and keep. The others will go on merrily doing what they please.
- The majority of the members of the Messianic Jewish Movement do not care for Judaism and much less for a what is already clearly “halacha” written in the Scripture why should they care about what some leaders have decided to bind on them.
- We do not want to make our own rules and regulations that will take us out of the fellowship of the people of Israel. There is nothing that will turn us into a sect faster than to make our own “rules and regulations” in either a conflict or in opposition to the Jewish Tradition. We can not start binding them upon people, both Jews and Gentiles, in the Messianic fellowships things that might widen the divide between us and the Jewish community. In fact the majority of the Messianic Fellowships in the United States are non-Jews, what kind of Halacha will you make that will be bound upon these people?
Halacha and God’s Grace
A follower of Yeshua must always take into account the principles of God’s grace. In doing Messianic Jewish Halacha we must stay as close to the Word of God as possible, but at the same time remember that our judgment will not be on the basis of what kind of toilet paper we use on Sabbath, but on the Grace of God through Yeshua’s sacrifice. This Grace of God, however, can not be taken as an a-priori consideration for making Halacha, it can only come into consideration as a post-priori extenuation of circumstances.
Matthew 23:1-4, and what it implies for Messianic Jewish Halacha today
Yeshua and His disciples are a part of the world of the Pharisees in the Land of Israel during the first century A.D. Yeshua was a Pharisee in His world view, and all the arguments that He had with the Pharisees were “in-house” arguments between co-religionists. The Pharisees had brought a religious revolution in Judaism in the first century B.C. That revolution was that God’s will can be known and discerned by any student from the Holy Scriptures. Before this great revolution and according to the Torah of Moses the way to discern the “Will of God” was to ask the Priest or the Prophet. When these two institutions were marred by corruption and Hellenism there developed a school that gleaned from the text of the Torah the passages that justified “study of the Torah” as a way of knowing God’s Will. It is with this school of thinking, the school of the Pharisees, that Yeshua and His disciples identify. This is also the reason why Yeshua is so involved and at times even angry with the Pharisees, they are the closest to Him. From the side of the Pharisees the same is true. Yeshua is considered to be one of them. That is why they come to him with accusations and questions of practice and tradition like the question about the washing of hands, and picking corn on the Sabbath. If he was a Sadducee they would not have even bothered to accuse him. We all argue with the people who are closest to us, and accuse of hypocrisy those whom we know best.
The meaning of Matthew 23:1-2, for us today can not be much different than the Apostles in the first century would have understood it. Here is my short exegesis of this passage:
Verse 1, Yeshua is speaking to both the crowds and his disciples. Why did the text see fit to mention this detail? The Holy Spirit through the text of the Gospel wanted all to know that the authority of the words of Yeshua in this case are applicable to both the crowds, in the first century context that would be “Am HaAretz,” and to Yeshua’s own disciples.
Verse 2, “The teachers of the Torah and the Pharisees sit in Moses’ seat.” Moses’ seat has been found in a number of synagogues dated to the period of the Mishnah. In the Synagogue Moses’ seat served as the pulpit does today. It was the place that the Rabbi would seat after the reading of the Torah and give his “Drasha” or “homily” in English. The concept behind this statement is hard to understand without remembering that the Jewish world of the second and third century B.C. underwent a great revolution. ￼The Pharisaic revolution in which the Tanach – God’s Holy Scriptures – became the standard by which man can know the will of God. In other words the text of the Tanach became the revelation of God. So, now study and interpretation were the means for discerning God’s will. Into this picture enters the Synagogue which was a place of gathering for the study and hearing of the Torah. So, the Rabbi who was in the line of authority from Moses had the right to exegete the text and draw practical or moral conclusions from the text. This was the earliest form of doing Halacha in the Jewish Community.
Yeshua is saying to the crowds and to his disciples that the teachers of the Torah and the Pharisees have the authority to interpret and make Halacha when they are explaining the text of the Torah of Moses.
Yeshua’s words here do not give a carte-blanche to the “teachers of the Torah” or to the “Pharisees” to make Halacha for the disciples of Yeshua. The statement limits them to the time that they “sit on Moses’ seat.” In other words, when they are actually exegeteing the text of the Torah in the Synagogue.
Verse 3a, It is very important to understand these words of Yeshua: “So you must obey them and do everything they tell you.” In the time of Yeshua there was not teaching against Him that was official and authoritative. In the near two thousand years of “Christian” history both the situation of the Jewish people and that of Christendom has changed significantly. Jewish tradition has made many Halachic rulings that are for polemic reasons against Christianity and Yeshua himself. I think that if we put the words of Yeshua back into the first century historical setting in which they were given we can still obey them and continue to give respect to the Jewish tradition of exegesis and interpretation of the Torah.
Verse 3b, The instruction that Yeshua gives here is very interesting and it reminds us of the words of King Yanai to his wife the Queen Sh’lom Zion. Yanai said to his wife, “do not be afraid of those who call themselves Pharisees. Be afraid of those who call themselves Pharisees and they are hypocrites.”
Verse 4, It is apparent that the problem was one of making many rules from the Torah and not keeping them themselves, or making demands and putting on burdens on the people without condensation for the practicality or the possibility of keeping them. The Torah was given for living not for theoreticians that live in the Beit Midrash and never have to deal with the daily and practical aspects of our faith.
Should the Messianic Jewish Movement do Halacha Now?
To answer the above question I must say both, “Yes!” and “No!” May be it is the right time to consider doing Messianic Jewish Halacha? As a movement that is still in a very transitional stage may be it is the right time to prepare for doing Messianic Jewish Halacha some time in the future? Is there a possibility for us to just accept the traditional Halacha on every subject that does not directly pertain on the person and character of Yeshua the Messiah? Since the majority of people attending and even leading Messianic Jewish Congregations are non-Jews or of questionable Jewish descent it might be that we ought to just forget about doing Halacha. It might be that we should just settle for the Protestant model and succumb to the weight of Western American Christian White Anglo-Saxon culture? We might not have the authority or the unity that is required to do a good job in formulating Halacha that will bless the Body of the Messiah and the people of Israel at this time?
It is easy to ask the above questions and point out the problems and the pitfalls or shortcomings of the Messianic Movement specially in respect to our Jewishness and Halacha. It is much harder to give concrete ￼and positive instructions as to “how to” do Messianic Jewish Halacha while guarding against some of the pitfalls and problems.
Some suggestions and rules for doing Messianic Jewish Halacha
The first rule for doing Halacha for today’s Messianic Community has to be, in my humble opinion, the acceptance of all the Halachic rulings and Apostolic examples and inferences that we find in the New Testament. One of the basic rules of doing Halacha is that you must build on what the previous generations handed down as authoritative. We can not do new Halacha by ignoring or outsmarting the Apostolic writers of God’s Inspired Word. Ignoring the rulings of the Apostles will make the Messianic Movement live up to the accusation of our Jewish brothers that we are a cult, and with them the Christian world will join with the same refrain. Signs of such trends are apparent when one looks at the way that such direct Apostolic commands as 1 Timothy 2:9-12, have been treated, ignored, and stumped upon by the leadership of the Messianic Movements in the United States. Doing Halacha can not become a tool for resolving political problems in the Messianic Movement. Doing Halacha has to be a sincere search for doing God’s will today in the Spirit and in the Truth of His Living Word.
The place to start doing Halacha today has to be Yeshua’s own instruction to His disciples recorded in Matthew 23:1-4.
If I am right on the above point it would imply that we must make a very serious effort to know and study and understand what do the Pharisees who sit in Moses’ seat say and teach on a variety of issues that we all face as Jews living in a post-modern world. How can we make Halacha that is Jewish if we, as the leaders of the Movement are connected by our umbilical cord to the Christian denominations. Many of us would be considered un-kosher to even be witnesses in court relating to matters of Jewish Law because we would be “Meshuchadim” (Bribed) in our thinking.
I realize that these words cut deep and hurt, but the first step for doing Halacha that would be valid and have credibility has to be an honest assessment of who we are today. Without this kind of honesty that hurts any Halacha that the Movement leaders would make would be short-lived and divisive to the Body of the Messiah and to Israel as a people.
The second step that we need to take as individuals and as a Movement is to explain or reason out the Biblical stance about “commandments” in relationship to God’s Grace and our unity with the rest of the Body of Christ. We do not want to alienate our non-Jewish Christian brothers who are still stranded on the unbalanced shores of Martin Luther’s understanding of God’s Grace. We want to present a good reasoned out theology and also a loving and friendly attitude without compromising the Word of God, or the Jewishness of the New Testament.
The third step that the Messianic Jewish Movement needs to take in order to do a credible Halacha is a commitment to unity and fellowship vis-à-vis all the arguments and disagreements that might arise during the process of doing Halacha. In doing Halacha all the possible disagreements and personality clashes that can arise do arise. There are vested interests and temperament issues that come up during such strong discussions and deliberations. The Messianic Jews must show at least the degree of tolerance and civilized behavior that the Pharisees showed to each other. We must remember that doing Halacha is working toward unity in both actions and doctrine. If doing Halacha will estrange us from each other, or from the Jewish community let us forget it, and just keep on doing each what is right in his own eyes.
The fourth step that the Messianic Jewish Movement must take in order to do Halacha is to recommit that the Word of God, and the Word of God alone, is the authority for our teaching and action. I have heard in a number of forums of Messianic Jews that through messages supposedly from the Holy Spirit they were given direction to do things diametrically opposed to the clear instructions of God’s Word. I believe that there has been a very bad influence on the Movement from certain movements in Christianity who have made the Holy Spirit of God “a dog that any one can go hunting with.” If the final authority for our actions is some supposed feeling, that one receives after a good pizza dinner, let us forget doing Messianic Jewish Halacha.
Fifth need for doing Messianic Jewish Halacha is time. It takes time, years, to develop the kind of respect and prestige that is necessary for the community to abide by the rulings of a committee. If we are going to have a Messianic Jewish Halacha in the future, which I hope we will have, it will take much time, some people who will work hard to gain the respect and the authority of God, and of the Movement. It will take scholarship and scholarship takes time to build and develop.
I have been negative enough in this article! It is time now to take the positive attitude. It is my firm conviction that with much good will from the part of the movement, and a broad enough base of people who are not rubber stamps of policy decisions made by the UMJC or the MJAA leadership, Biblical and Jewish Halacha can be built up for the future generations of Messianic Jews. Start by preparing a sufficient moral and financial support for those who will do the task, and than choose the people not according to their political affiliation in the Movement, but according to their spiritual and intellectual qualification as honest students of God’s Word.
9 thoughts on “Doing Messianic Jewish Halacha”
The way I see there is not much interest on the part of rabbinical and messianic leadership to teach people how exegete the text of the Tanach! The leaders present eloquent speeches and produce insghtful books and articles for sale. Unfortunately rarely one finds practical teaching in exegeting and applying the Scriptures… People are left in the dark as far being taught to handle text. I myself would love to learn Jewish exegesis and exposition of the Hebrew Scriptures!
I crave it but can’t find it either.
This article is excellent and heartbreaking. It is filled with wonderful insight and clear truth.
And honestly, the truth is not easy to hear. As one who is counted from among the “nations,” my heart, mind and attention was turned to TORAH 5 years ago.
Since then my former religious affiliations were shattered. Today, practicing Halacha is rebuked and derided here among Christian churches. Many of us are being kicked out, asked to leave the churches for returning to any expression of TORAH obedience; whether it’s the Sabbath, eating kosher or celebrating the feasts. If leaders find out you are doing any of those things we are being called, Judaizers, family members send is verses of Pauls letters to refute our lifestyles. We are told we are in a cult and we are just trying to put others back under the law.
Meanwhile well know pastors are saying there should be no association of christians with the law: NOT EVEN THE 10 COMMANDMENTS! Andy Stanely who oversees a congregation of 33,000 members here in America just said that publicly.
What are we to do? I am ready to abandon all of the divisiveness of floating between Christian doctrine and Messianic division and convert to orthodox Judaism.
At least they are anchored to the TORAH, the foundation Rabbi Yeshua was building on. Its really frustrating.
I am not even Jewish but I know I don’t want to spend my life languishing in a “no mans land” accepting the Messiah but being hostile to the TORAH of Moshe. Likewise in Orthodoxy I dont want to attach myself to TORAH and the teachings of the rabbis and have to be hostile to Rabbi Yeshua. His halacha was not burdensome and I am really happy to understand as much as I do!
Finding a household of faith into which our family could fold into; one that holds the words of Moshe in the same high regard that Rabbi Yeshua (and all his talmidim) did would be a dream come true!
I was JUST thinking about these exact problems within the faith of those who have come to Messiah as Christians, but have continued to grow and search and understood that the Torah is God’s Divine Light!
The way I see it, most churches are operated like businesses. (especially when they’ve got 250+ members.)
They’re houses of idolatry in the sense that the focus is always the church itself. (as opposed to being Israeli-centered in their mindset. This is the allure of the temple.–A central point to which we can all raise our eyes.) Your tithe goes right into the building. But the church doesn’t usually have a welfare program for its widows like it should (and like the apostles did!)
It feels much more like a cultural center, and like a club, and people in churches are not seeking truth! they’ve accepted the Denominational “Halacha”, be it Pentecostal, Baptist, or Catholic!
To me, this is the same is in the Torah. At mount Sinai Israel received the Light of the Word of God and immedietly built a Calf and worshiped God their way.
likewise we have seen the Light of God’s Word in the flesh! And immediately the Catholic church made a golden calf out of Him.
IT has always been the Righteous have “hidden in caves” like the 7000 in the time of Eliyahu. And so this is our Creed! the Remnant who sees truth!
And that is why we work so hard to teach the Jewish roots of our faith to all, Jew and Gentile aline.
What about “Actionable Steps”? I am a “member of the nations”, but given the chance (as given by the other forms of Judaism) I would “convert”. I left Protestantism for a reason. I felt that it was not being faithful to the Scriptures. There were claims of the validity of all Scriptures, but de facto, the New Testament is considered the “Primary authority”, with the Old Testament used for sporatic support.
My desire is to be faithful to G-d and to His Word. I want to learn His ways and to follow – obediently… unquestioningly (when He is concerned, not unquestioningly follow a person’s interpretation).
But back to my point, we have to get beyond the “identifying the problem” step. It seems this is the majority of what people do – Talk About The Problem.
Let’s do something!
Maybe it starts by gathering people, who are in search of authenticity. Maybe that’s a Facebook group, hopefully an International group, not simply one dominated by Americans (I am an American citizen, by the way.)
I think that Action Steps are needed.
The biggest problem that I have had is simply, I want to learn Jewish traditions, yet a fear getting to intimate with the Orthodox Synagogues, because I know that my belief in Yeshua will ultimately cause friction.
(My opinion is that there will probably either be a split in the Messianic Movement, one focusing on actually being “Jewish” and the other taking the a la carte approach to Christianity and Judaism, or the movement will simply be reabsorbed back into the Protestant family, just being a Saturday meeting group.)
I think there is a good chance you are correct regarding your prediction for the future of the Messianic movement.
There is many small actions taking place such as you finding us, but nothing on a grand scale yet. The Messianic movement needs to solve its identity crisis as to its relationship with traditional Judaism before it can make solid steps forward.
I enjoyed the article. Thank you. I offer two thoughts for your consideration. First, I personally think it is clear from Acts 15 and Acts 21, that, as is taught in traditional Judaism, there are differing halachic requirements for Jews versus Gentiles. Second, I think the way to understand the authority to bind and loose given to the disciples/apostles on the one hand, and yet the admonition to observe what the Pharisees teach is as follows: The Pharisees were to maintain there position as the interpreters of the Torah – even for the Messianic communities…But the apostles would make halachic rulings for the Messianic communities – they would determine which ruling to follow and settle disputes etc. In other words, the Messianic communities established their own beit din (house of judgement/courts) but made their decisions based on the halacha of the Rabbis/(Pharisees)
Loved the article. I always had a question;
Why didnt the disciples wrote a halachic code? Because they where 100% integrated in the first century jewish nation!
I believe that what is legislated by the Sanhedrin is binding to all Jews (and the first followers of Yeshua practice it), was is legislated by bate dinim ketonim (small courts) are for communal purposes and are not binding to all Israel.
Thats why we should study Talmud. But we should differentiate between the whole Talmud and what is Oral Law. The Talmud is not the Oral Law but the Oral Law is in the Talmud specifically in the Mishnah. The Mishnah was what R. Yehudda haNasi wrote. But is the Mishnah the Oral Law? No! But the Oral Law is in the Mishnah. What is actually Oral Law is what was legislated by the Sanhedrin (Bet Din haGadol).
I have another interpretation of “The Seat of Moses” that does not contradict what you wrote but expands it.
Rabenu haMashiach said:
Then spoke Yeshua to the multitude and to His disciples, saying, “The scribes and the Pharisees sit in Moses’ seat. All therefore whatsoever they bid you observe, that observe and do; but do ye not according to their works; for they say, and do not.”
To me “Moses Seat” is a reference to the Sanhedrin in the broder sence. I doesnt contradict the idea of the synagoge seat where the Rabbis gave the drasha, and teach halakha based on the Sanhedrins desitions, both interpretations are coherent.
Rambam wrote in the Mishneh Torah:
“How many regular courts of law are to be in Israel, and how many members should each include? To begin with, a supreme court named Great Sanhedrin is established in the Temple; it consists of seventy-one members, as it is written: “Gather for me seventy of the elders of Israel,” presided over by Moses, as it is written: “Let them present themselves beside you” Numbers 11:16-17), thus totaling seventy-one. The greatest sage among them all is appointed their presiding officer, who also serves as head of the academy. He is designated by the sages as Nasi (president), who occupies the position of our teacher Moses.”
And as Pirke Abot says:
“Moses received the Torah at Sinai and transmitted it to Joshua, Joshua to the elders, and the elders to the prophets, and the prophets to the Men of the Great Assembly. They said three things: Be patient in [the administration of] justice, raise many disciples and make a fence round the Torah.”
What should Messianics should do? Observe the written Torah, observe the real Oral Torah and the teachings of Yeshua.
This is how I interpret this verses:
Then spoke Yeshua to the multitude and to His disciples, saying, “The scribes and the Pharisees sit on the Sanhedrin. All therefore whatsoever the Sanhedrin bid you observe, that observe and do; but do ye not according to the works of the common scribes and Pharisees; for they say to follow the Sanhedrin, and do not.”
And the next verse I interprete it as follow:
For they bind heavy burdens (minhaguim as halakhot) and grievous to be borne, and lay them on men’s shoulders, but they themselves will not move them with one of their fingers.
What is legislated by the Sanhedrin is binding to all Jews, was is legislated by bate dinim ketonim (small courts) are for communal purposes and are not binding to all Israel. The rest of the Talmud is commentary. It should be studied but it should not be exalted as Oral Law. Most orthodox don’t make the distinction. Also most orthodox teach latter halachic decisions by Rabbis and Dayanim as if they are binding to all Israel but that’s not correct. That’s on the category of mihagim (customs) and we as Talmide Rabenu haMashiach cannot follow customs as halakhot as it is written:
“You have disregarded the commandment of God to keep the tradition of men. He went on to say, You neatly set aside the command of God to maintain your own tradition.”
Minhaguim are not necesarily bad but we should not be elevate them as halakha and as obligatory. The only Code of Jewish Law that’s based on the Mishnah is the Mishne Torah. The Shulkhan Arukh and others are based on what the people did and not on what the Mishnah says so it haves a lot of Minhaguin as halakhot wich in my opinion is not correct.
This is why there is no Halakhic Code made by the first disciples, they where part of the Jewish nation and they follow the Sanhedrin. Now, I don’t think we should call ourself orthodox Messiancs but Halakhic Messianics.
The divition of Orthodox, Conservative and Reform is a Ashkenasi phenomenom and it wasn’t part of Yehuas jewish view. Halakhic Judaism doesn’t have those divitions. The sefardic community before the influence of ashkenasi division preserved the ancient way. The community is halakhic and observant but all levels of observance where included and in the synagogue where motivated to grow in observance.
If we follow strictly whats is required in the real Oral Law preserved in the Mishnah in prayer, for example, we would have a shorter Siddur and that is coherent with what Rabenu teach us when he said:
“And when you pray, do not babble on like pagans, for they think that by their many words they will be heard.”
That would lessen the “burden” and will give us time for pouring kavanah to our prayers . This also apply on other parts of jewish life. What is demanded in the written and oral Torah is far less of what is demanded by orthodox judaism.